Thinking & Decisions

Why do we want to believe anything?

Even in a dream, the sense of agency remains active. In the story of the dream, the dreamer is a passive observer who may experience himself as a rock, a horse, or a table. This raises an interesting ...

Varun Rao
Varun Rao
2025-07-23·3 min read
Why do we want to believe anything?
Editorial visual for Why do we want to believe anything?

Even in a dream, the sense of agency remains active. In the story of the dream, the dreamer is a passive observer who may experience himself as a rock, a horse, or a table. This raises an interesting question: why does a person remember, feel, and experience everything centered around the self? Can there be experiences without self-centeredness? What does it mean to be able to relate to others? And finally, is it possible to understand this better to live a happy, fulfilling life? Imagine a child with no name, raised without ever using personal pronouns; could such a child eventually develop a coherent sense of self?

Subjective experience is a clever solution the mind has developed to survive in the world. This results in a coherent sense of self, allowing the future self to view the present as a continuation of the past. One can become a new person in an instant if they think so, but their memories will disagree. Those memories carry evidence accessible to the conscious mind. For example, a criminal who has lost all memory of a past crime may truly believe he is innocent.

The real problem is that the mind wants to believe in something. When this sense of coherence begins to fall apart, the person becomes dysfunctional. The mind panics, fighting desperately to keep believing its memories. Sometimes we become aware of this while conversing with people who hold opposing beliefs. Even when there's enough evidence to prove our beliefs are flawed, we still prefer to hold on to them. To change one set of beliefs, we need to have trust in another set of beliefs firmer than the older ones.

We also willingly create fantasies, construct stories, and lie to ourselves. When questioned, why to believe this, someone might say, “I just want to be happy and peaceful.” This suggests the presence of two entities: one that wants to avoid confrontation with reality, and another that knows the truth. The human mind, a far superior pattern-recognition machine, evolved over the years to accurately assess both reality and deception. Its job was to protect us from danger, even if it was an internal one.

When beliefs are shattered and the coherent self begins to collapse, the mind sends waves of signals, causing the host to experience overwhelming anxiety. To be happy, our values, beliefs, and actions should align. As long as we have memories and life, we will have a coherent sense of self. We should continue to live accepting the past as it cannot be changed, and live the present in alignment with our values.

· · ·
Varun Rao

Varun Rao

Writer & Technologist

Writing on careers, AI autonomy, mental models, and the evolving nature of work. If this essay made you reflect, explore the topic hub or subscribe for periodic dispatches.

Dialogue & Amplification

Share this Essay

If this piece prompted reflection, challenged your assumptions, or provided value, share it with colleagues or start a discussion on LinkedIn.

Discussion

0

Join the conversation

Sign in with Google to post your thoughts, reply to other readers, and like insightful reflections.

No comments yet.

Be the first to share an insight or question.

Related ExplorationsAll essays →

Unit tests for life

Unit tests for life are small dosages of crafted sentences that makes you think and deeply reflect about your own circumstance. It should not be taken as checklist to carry around.

·2 min read

The thinking tools to understand daily events

This principle of physics has much relevance in our day-to-day life. People who behave and believe in something will continue to operate similarly unless something dramatic happens in their lives. It also means that changing beliefs needs effort; the push to change the beliefs may come from internal conflicts or external pressure. Equilibrium is a state where opposing forces that are acting on a body cancel each other out. One can stand still on a floor because the floor is exerting an equal and opposite force on him. The initial excitement fades in marriage, and over time, both settle into unwritten agreements. On either side, the behavior shifts to reduce psychological pain, such as disappointments, and to maximize the pleasure until it reaches an equilibrium.

·3 min read
Why do we want to believe anything? — Varun Rao — Varun Rao